92 Comments
User's avatar
Becca L's avatar

This is by far the best recipe I have ever come across for Mac&Cheese. (I have tried many!)

Expand full comment
Ms. G's avatar

MY FAVORiTE RECiPE TiNi 🫶🏽🩷

Expand full comment
Hannah Baker's avatar

I have celiac and made this with banza cavatappi and GF flour and it was still sooo delicious! Best Mac and cheese I’ve ever had even pre celiac lol

Expand full comment
Chris Fuller's avatar

Made this today and added chunks of peppercorn bacon (about 12 oz.), also used some bacon grease in making the roux. Will report back with results.

Expand full comment
Chris Fuller's avatar

The bacon grease made the whole dish just a little too greasy, definitely sticking with just butter from here on. Also made this again using extra sharp cheddar and pepper jack instead of colby, which really robustified the flavor.

Expand full comment
Emily Ralph's avatar

Made this tonight! It was awesome. Question though, the mozzarella wasn’t completely melting. Do you use part skim or whole milk mozzarella? I’m suspecting the part skim was to blame.

Expand full comment
Tini Younger's avatar

Whole

Expand full comment
Emily Ralph's avatar

Thank you!!

Expand full comment
Jennifer Bragg's avatar

YES MA’AM I luv this recipe!!! 🫶🙌

Expand full comment
heber christopherson's avatar

Best recipe I've ever made! Thank you!

Expand full comment
Kendall's avatar

I made this for FriendsGiving and I almost didn't get any myself. Everyone said it was delicious!

Expand full comment
Rian Graves's avatar

I am love with this recipe! Just tried it for Halloween and my family LOVED IT! I will be making this every year from now on!

Expand full comment
Hope Ray's avatar

How can we print it out

Expand full comment
Mia's avatar

how much does this recipe make for?

Expand full comment
mystiknitter's avatar

12? Made this for Thanksgiving (along with turkey, many sides and appetizers), and it was luscious, very filling. Very filling.

Expand full comment
Emily's avatar

If I am making it the day before, do I prepare everything and layer it in the dish, then cover and refrigerate until I am ready to bake the next day? Or do I wait to layer it until I am about to bake it the day of?

Expand full comment
Summer Lamar's avatar

I’m wondering the same 😩

Expand full comment
Emily's avatar

I made it last night, layered it, and covered it in the fridge. I’m baking it this evening so I’ll let you know how it turns out!

Expand full comment
Summer Lamar's avatar

Amazing!!!! Looking forward to hearing about it! Thank you!

Expand full comment
Emily's avatar

It was great!! I will say maybe bake it for 30-35 minutes before broiling. It took a little bit longer to heat up since it was in the refrigerator for 24 hours!

Expand full comment
Summer Lamar's avatar

Perfect!!! Thank you!!!

Expand full comment
Adriana Lievirisci's avatar

can you update us on how it was please?

Expand full comment
Evelyn's avatar

tini do we use unsalted butter? :)

Expand full comment
Tini Younger's avatar

I use salted butter for cooking unsalted for baking.

Expand full comment
Evelyn's avatar

thank you!🩷

Expand full comment
SSan's avatar

unsalted butter is always better to avoid making it super salty!

Expand full comment
Evelyn's avatar

okok i figured just wanted to double check thank u!! :’)

Expand full comment
Brianna Cook's avatar

Would i be able to prep this completely the night before, put it in the fridge, and bake right before serving the next day? Would i need to change anything?

Expand full comment
Lee Gordon's avatar

Cook the pasta 7 minutes instead of 8 if making the night before.

Expand full comment
Princess Nancy's avatar

What size can of evaporated milk?

Expand full comment
Idalis Logan's avatar

Attempting to make this for the third time for Easter (today) and my in laws will be having it for the first time ever ! I’ll come back and say how it all went.

Expand full comment